Current:Home > InvestAbortion ban upheld by South Carolina Supreme Court in reversal of previous ruling -Blueprint Wealth Network
Abortion ban upheld by South Carolina Supreme Court in reversal of previous ruling
View
Date:2025-04-19 13:57:45
South Carolina's new all-male Supreme Court reversed course on abortion Wednesday, upholding a law banning most such procedures except in the earliest weeks of pregnancy.
The continued erosion of legal abortion access across the U.S. South comes after Republican state lawmakers replaced the lone woman on the court, Justice Kaye Hearn, who reached the state's mandatory retirement age.
The 4-1 ruling departs from the court's own decision months earlier striking down a similar ban that the Republican-led legislature passed in 2021. The latest ban takes effect immediately.
Writing for the new majority, Justice John Kittredge acknowledged that the 2023 law also infringes on "a woman's right of privacy and bodily autonomy," but said the state Legislature reasonably determined this time around that those interests don't outweigh "the interest of the unborn child to live."
"As a Court, unless we can say that the balance struck by the Legislature was unreasonable as a matter of law, we must uphold the Act," Kittredge wrote.
Kittredge wrote that "we leave for another day" a determination on what the law's language means for when exactly during a pregnancy the ban should begin, likely forecasting another long court fight on that question.
Chief Justice Donald Beatty provided the lone dissent, arguing that the 2023 law is nearly identical, with definitions for terms including "fetal heartbeat" and "conception" that provide no clarity on when the ban begins, exposing doctors to criminal charges if law enforcement disagrees with their expertise.
The 2023 law restricts most abortions once cardiac activity can be detected, declaring that this happens about six weeks after a pregnant woman's last menstrual period. Lawmakers defined this as "the steady and repetitive rhythmic contraction of the fetal heart, within the gestational sac."
But Beatty wrote that at six weeks, the fetus doesn't exist yet — it's still an embryo — and the heart doesn't develop until later in a pregnancy. The American College of Obstetricians and Gynecologists says it's inaccurate to call such "cardiac activity" a heartbeat.
"The terminology is medically and scientifically inaccurate. As such, it is the quintessential example of political gaslighting; attempting to manipulate public opinion and control the reproductive health decisions of women by distorting reality," Beatty wrote.
The Planned Parenthood South Atlantic clinic in Columbia had served only a "handful" of the roughly 30 patients scheduled for abortions Wednesday when the ruling came down, according to Dr. Katherine Farris, the group's chief medical officer. The center — one of three clinics in the state — has paused abortions while officials work to understand the ruling's implications.
Beatty warned that the majority's failure to address such a key question could lead to political retribution. He added that judicial independence and integrity were weakened by the court's decision to backpedal on its prior ruling.
Hearn wrote the majority's lead opinion in January, striking down the ban as a violation of the state constitution's right to privacy. She then reached the court's mandatory retirement age, enabling the GOP-led Legislature to put Gary Hill on what is now the nation's only state Supreme Court with an entirely male bench.
Republican lawmakers then crafted a new law to address Justice John Few's concern, expressed in the January ruling, that the Legislature had failed to take into account whether the restrictions were reasonable enough to infringe upon a woman's privacy rights.
The new law was opposed by the only five women in the state Senate, a bipartisan group who refer to themselves as the "Sister Senators."
"I cried this morning, actually, with — I feel like so much weight was on our shoulders, not just for South Carolina, but Florida, Georgia, the Southeast now," Republican Sen. Sandy Senn told CBS News in May.
Abortion providers, including Planned Parenthood South Atlantic, sued again. Planned Parenthood South Atlantic's lawyer said during oral arguments this summer that both laws limited abortions at the same point in pregnancy and were equally unconstitutional.
The newly sworn Hill joined Wednesday's majority along with Few, who had previously voted to overturn the 2021 law. In a separate concurring opinion, Few wrote that the state constitution's right to privacy does not provide blanket protections against "reasonable" invasions.
The majority opinion found a key difference in the lawmakers' deletion of a reference to a pregnant woman having the right to make an "informed choice." The 2023 law expanded "the notion of choice to the period of time before fertilization, certainly before a couple passively learns of a pregnancy," Few wrote.
That change lengthens the window for couples to avoid unwanted pregnancies by promoting "active family planning." In addition, the new law provides insured contraceptives to "almost all couples" and places responsibility on sexually active couples to actively use pregnancy tests, Few wrote.
Planned Parenthood South Atlantic's lawyer had noted during oral arguments that such analysis ignored the possibility for failures in testing and contraceptives.
Since the U.S. Supreme Court last year overturned Roe v. Wade, the 1973 ruling that provided nationwide access to abortion, most GOP-controlled states have enacted or adopted abortion bans of some kind. All have been challenged in court.
Republican officials in South Carolina celebrated what Gov. Henry McMaster called "the culmination of years of hard work" to curtail abortion access. Republican legislative leaders scrambled at the end of the session to pass the new limits as the number of abortions increased rapidly under the state's reversion to a 22-week ban passed in 2016.
Republican South Carolina Senate Majority Leader Shane Massey said Wednesday that he anticipates future challenges based on the definition of cardiac activity. Still, he expects the new ruling will put the issue to rest next session.
That is, at least until 2024 elections possibly alter the composition of a state Senate that fell just shy several times this past year of clearing procedural hurdles to enact a near-total ban.
More court shakeups are also coming. Beatty must retire in 2024 because he, too, will reach the mandated retirement age of 72 for judges. Kittredge is the only judge who applied to replace him. The Legislature is expected to approve Kittredge and choose another new justice next year.
- In:
- South Carolina
- Roe v. Wade
- Abortion
veryGood! (5)
Related
- Moving abroad can be expensive: These 5 countries will 'pay' you to move there
- Bradley Cooper Reacts to Controversy Over Wearing Prosthetic Nose in Maestro
- Bradley Cooper Reacts to Controversy Over Wearing Prosthetic Nose in Maestro
- Military scientists identify remains of Indiana soldier who died in German WWII battle
- Cincinnati Bengals quarterback Joe Burrow owns a $3 million Batmobile Tumbler
- Aaron Rodgers has 'personal guilt' about how things ended for Zach Wilson with the Jets
- Germany and Italy agree on joint ‘action plan’ including energy, technology, climate protection
- Photos show a shocked nation mourning President John F. Kennedy after assassination
- Why we love Bear Pond Books, a ski town bookstore with a French bulldog 'Staff Pup'
- See the first photo of Eddie Murphy as Axel Foley in 'Beverly Hills Cop 4' film on Netflix
Ranking
- How to watch new prequel series 'Dexter: Original Sin': Premiere date, cast, streaming
- Truce deal raises hopes of freeing hostages in Gaza and halting worst Mideast violence in decades
- Pope Francis meets with relatives of Israeli hostages and Palestinian prisoners
- King Charles honors Blackpink for environmental efforts: See photos
- Opinion: Gianni Infantino, FIFA sell souls and 2034 World Cup for Saudi Arabia's billions
- Regulators and law enforcement crack down on crypto’s bad actors. Congress has yet to take action
- Hailey Bieber Drops a Shimmering Version of the Viral Rhode Lip Tint Just in Time for the Holidays
- 'Fargo' Season 5: Cast, schedule, trailer, how to watch episode 3
Recommendation
Tarte Shape Tape Concealer Sells Once Every 4 Seconds: Get 50% Off Before It's Gone
Palestinian flag displayed by fans of Scottish club Celtic at Champions League game draws UEFA fine
Travis Kelce inspires Chipotle to temporarily change its name after old Tweets resurface
An American sexual offender convicted in Kenya 9 years ago is rearrested on new assault charges
Stamford Road collision sends motorcyclist flying; driver arrested
Police identify man they say injured 4 in Beavercreek, Ohio Walmart shooting
Kaley Cuoco Reveals Why Her Postpartum Fitness Routine Is Good For My Body and Heart
Coldplay concert in Malaysia can be stopped by organizers if the band misbehaves, government says